The State of Forensic Science in Criminal Investigation in Nigeria: Challenges, Prospects and Policy Directions.

Forensic science remains relatively underdeveloped within Nigeria’s criminal justice system despite the increasing sophistication of contemporary crimes, including terrorism, banditry, kidnapping for ransom, cybercrime, homicide, sexual violence, human trafficking, and financial crimes. Criminal investigations continue to rely heavily on confession statements, eyewitness testimony, and traditional policing approaches, with limited integration of scientific evidence. This reliance has contributed to delayed justice delivery, weak prosecution outcomes, wrongful convictions, prolonged pre-trial detention, prison overcrowding, and declining public confidence in law enforcement institutions and the justice system. This article examines the current state of forensic science in criminal investigation in Nigeria, focusing on institutional capacity, operational constraints, emerging developments, and future policy directions. The study adopts a qualitative research approach based on an analysis of secondary literature, legislative instruments, institutional reports, policy documents, and comparative experiences from other jurisdictions. The findings reveal significant structural and operational challenges, including inadequate forensic infrastructure, shortages of specialised personnel, fragmented regulatory frameworks, inconsistent funding, weak quality assurance mechanisms, corruption and political interference, limited inter-agency coordination, and insufficient digital forensic capacity to address technology-driven crimes. Despite these challenges, the study identifies important developments that demonstrate the potential for forensic transformation in Nigeria. These include the establishment of the Lagos State DNA and Forensic Centre, the development of forensic laboratories and training facilities in Kaduna and Enugu States, expanded forensic capacity within the National Drug Law Enforcement Agency, improvements associated with United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime-supported forensic initiatives, and gradual legal reforms under the Administration of Criminal Justice Act 2015, state-level criminal justice reforms, and the Police Act 2020. Drawing on procedural justice theory, the article argues that forensic science is not merely a technical instrument for crime detection but also a critical component of institutional legitimacy, procedural fairness, and public trust. The article concludes that sustainable forensic development requires a comprehensive national forensic science policy, coordinated institutional architecture, long-term investment in regional forensic laboratories, accreditation and quality assurance systems, specialised human capital development, strengthened evidence management procedures, improved digital forensic capabilities, and safeguards to ensure scientific independence and integrity. Such reforms would enhance investigative accuracy, strengthen prosecution outcomes, protect against miscarriages of justice, and contribute to a more credible and effective criminal justice system in Nigeria.

Keywords: Forensic Science, Criminal Investigation, Nigeria, Criminal Justice, Policy Developments